1540 E. Maryland Ave., Suite 100B
Phoenix, AZ 85014
Call For Your 30 Min Case Evaluation

September 2026 | Article 16
A criminal case can leave a financial obligation that continues after sentencing. If you face charges in Phoenix or elsewhere in Arizona, a request for restitution deserves attention while the case is still being evaluated.
Restitution generally requires a convicted person to repay the victim's qualifying economic loss caused by the offense. The amount can involve more than the first bill or repair estimate. Understanding what is being claimed, why it is connected to the offense, and how it was calculated helps you make informed decisions.
Under A.R.S. § 13-603(C), the court generally must order the full amount of qualifying economic loss. Depending on the circumstances, that can include medical expenses, property loss, and lost earnings.
Arizona's definition of economic loss excludes pain and suffering, punitive damages, consequential damages, and the convicted person's own losses. Consequential damages are a legal category involving losses that do not flow directly from the criminal conduct. Whether a particular expense falls within that category can require careful analysis.
The connection matters. An expense appearing after an incident does not, by itself, establish that the offense directly caused it. The defense should examine the facts behind each category of loss.
Restitution is not limited to expenses already paid or wages already missed. In E.H. v. Slayton (2025), the Arizona Supreme Court confirmed that reasonably anticipated future economic losses, including lost earnings, can qualify when the criminal conduct directly caused them.
The amount still needs a reasonable evidentiary basis. An expert's assumptions, treatment projections, employment records, and other supporting information may need review. A loss is not automatically excluded because it will occur later or is difficult to calculate.
A complete review may include invoices, repair estimates, photographs, wage records, insurance documents, and relevant testimony. Receipts can be useful, but they are not the only way to establish a loss.
For a property claim, questions might include whether the estimate covers damage from this incident or earlier damage, and whether an item was recovered. A lost-wages request may require examining the dates missed, the pay rate, and the reason the person could not work. The goal is to identify the actual loss supported by the evidence.
Under A.R.S. § 13-804, the court does not use the defendant's financial circumstances to reduce the amount of qualifying restitution. Those circumstances do matter when deciding how restitution will be paid, along with the victim's views.
Insurance reimbursement also does not automatically eliminate restitution. It can affect who receives payment. Keep documentation of reimbursements and prior payments so the court has a complete picture.
A defendant must have notice and an opportunity to challenge a restitution request. Depending on the evidence and the dispute, the court may hold a restitution hearing. A separate hearing is not required in every case.
Bring disputed amounts and supporting records to your lawyer promptly. Do not contact a victim to negotiate payment if a court order prohibits contact. Do not assume that a private payment will resolve the criminal case or satisfy an eventual court order.
If restitution is part of your Arizona criminal case, call The Molina Law Group at (602) 718-1249 or request a case evaluation. Our Phoenix office can discuss the claimed losses, supporting evidence, and your options before you make a decision.
Learn more about our criminal defense representation in Phoenix.
This article is general information about Arizona law, not legal advice for a particular case. Outcomes depend on the facts and applicable law.