1540 E. Maryland Ave., Suite 100B
Phoenix, AZ 85014

The Molina Law Group PLLC

Call For Your 30 Min Case Evaluation

(602) 718-1249

The Molina Law Group PLLC

What to Expect During a Criminal Preliminary Hearing in Arizona

  • Published: November 8, 2024
Judge reviewing probable cause

Being charged with a felony in Arizona is a serious matter, and one of the first critical steps in the process is the preliminary hearing. This hearing serves as a gatekeeper function—it determines whether there is enough evidence for your case to move forward to trial. Understanding what happens during a preliminary hearing, and how to prepare, could be the difference between having your charges reduced, dismissed, or pursued in superior court.

What Is a Preliminary Hearing?

A preliminary hearing—also called a probable cause hearing—is a legal proceeding where the judge decides whether the prosecution has shown enough evidence to justify continuing the case. It’s not a trial, and the defendant does not have to prove innocence. The burden is on the prosecution to demonstrate that:
– A crime was committed, and
– There is reasonable belief (probable cause) that the accused committed it.

If the State seeks to conduct a preliminary hearing instead of presenting charges to a Grand Jury, then these hearings generally take place in the Superior Court. (Some Jurisdictions conduct these hearings in Justice Courts) Probable cause determinations are required for the government to seek Felony charges. Misdemeanor cases typically bypass this stage and proceed directly to trial or plea negotiations.

What Happens During the Hearing?

At the hearing, the prosecutor will present evidence, such as:
– Police reports
– Witness testimony
– Physical evidence
– Surveillance footage (if applicable)

The judge will consider whether this evidence meets the threshold of probable cause. While the standard is lower than at trial, it still requires the prosecution to offer more than speculation.

Your defense attorney will have the opportunity to:
– Cross-examine witnesses
– Challenge the admissibility or credibility of evidence
– Highlight gaps or inconsistencies in the prosecution’s case

In many cases, this is the first time your attorney can see how the state plans to argue its case—and begin building your defense in response.

Possible Outcomes of a Preliminary Hearing

There are three general outcomes from a preliminary hearing:

  1. Case is Bound Over for Trial
    If the judge finds probable cause, your case moves forward with arraignment and further proceedings.
  2. Charges Are Dismissed
    If the judge finds the evidence insufficient, the charges can be dropped. However, the prosecutor may refile the charges with additional evidence.
  3. Charges Are Reduced
    In some cases, the judge may determine that the evidence supports a lesser offense, and charges may be downgraded (e.g., from felony to misdemeanor).

Why Legal Representation Is So Important

Preliminary hearings may move quickly, but they offer a valuable opportunity for your defense attorney to:
– Expose weaknesses in the prosecution’s case
– Negotiate early plea deals
– Argue for a reduction in charges
– Push for outright dismissal before trial

An experienced Arizona criminal defense lawyer will know how to take full advantage of this stage—reviewing the evidence, filing motions if necessary, and advocating for your rights before the case progresses further.

What You Should Do to Prepare

If you’ve been charged with a felony in Arizona and a preliminary hearing is scheduled, here’s how to prepare:
– Hire a criminal defense attorney immediately: Do not face this alone.
– Gather documentation: Provide your lawyer with all relevant materials (e.g., witness names, texts, alibis).
– Avoid discussing the case: Do not talk about your charges with anyone other than your lawyer.
– Stay in close contact with your legal team: Preparation and communication are key.

Protect Your Rights from the Start

At Molina Law Group, we understand that the early stages of a criminal case can shape the entire outcome. Our firm aggressively defends clients during preliminary hearings, pushing back against weak or unlawful charges and fighting for the best possible resolution.

Contact us today for a confidential consultation and learn how we can begin building your defense immediately.

Edwin A. Molina III

The Molina Law Group focuses on Criminal Defense - Call Us Now - (602) 718-1249